THERMAL LAB · EN-04 · ENGINEERING NOTES
What a data sheet does not tell you
A data sheet is a statement about one sample, new, flat and clean, in one test. A product uses that material creased, compressed, layered and worn. The distance between the two is where most thermal designs go wrong.
In this section
- EN-01 Why a heated jacket heats two rectangles
- EN-02 Warm air beats hot pads
- EN-03 The watt is the unit of warmth
- EN-04 What a data sheet does not tell you
- EN-05 Thin is a thermal property
- EN-06 Why we measure in watt-hours
- EN-07 The jacket you already own
- EN-08 The cost of an air leak
- EN-09 Feet and hands follow the core
- EN-10 Heating people, not rooms
- EN-11 Cold is a battery problem too
- EN-12 Why 45 °C is not hot, and why it is
- EN-13 The operating room as a test environment
- EN-14 Designing for the wash
- EN-15 What thermal cameras get wrong
Four things that are usually missing
The conditions. A heater's surface temperature is given without saying whether it was in open air or under insulation. The same element can differ by 20 °C (36 °F) between the two.
The location. A single temperature for a heating element does not say whether it is the center, the edge or the average.
The time. Warm-up to rated temperature may take one minute or fifteen.
The spread. A typical value is given. The variation between samples and between production lots is not.
Insulation
Thermal conductivity is measured on an uncompressed sample. Under a strap the material is thinner and denser, and it insulates less. A perforated version shares the data sheet of the solid one, though the holes pass heat freely.
Heat-reflective materials
Emittance is measured on a clean surface facing open space. In a garment the surface may touch another layer, in which case it conducts and its emittance is irrelevant. After washing, the figure may no longer apply at all.
Batteries
Capacity is given at room temperature and a gentle discharge rate. In the cold, at the current a heater draws, a pack delivers less. The label also quotes capacity at the cell voltage, before conversion losses.
What to do about it
Data sheets are for shortlisting. They tell you which candidates are worth testing. The decision should rest on a measurement of the material in the stack, under the conditions of use, against the alternative.
We run that comparison as a matter of routine. More than once a material that led on paper has come second on the bench, and the reason was visible in a thermal image within minutes.
A fair word for suppliers
Most data sheets are accurate for what they state. The problem is seldom bad faith. A supplier cannot know your stack, your compression or your air gap. Only a test in your configuration can.
See side-by-side comparison and the materials library.