THERMAL LAB · EN-15 · ENGINEERING NOTES
What thermal cameras get wrong
A thermal image looks like a photograph of temperature. It is a calculation based on assumptions, and when the assumptions are wrong the image is wrong in ways that are not visible. Five errors account for most of the trouble.
In this section
- EN-01 Why a heated jacket heats two rectangles
- EN-02 Warm air beats hot pads
- EN-03 The watt is the unit of warmth
- EN-04 What a data sheet does not tell you
- EN-05 Thin is a thermal property
- EN-06 Why we measure in watt-hours
- EN-07 The jacket you already own
- EN-08 The cost of an air leak
- EN-09 Feet and hands follow the core
- EN-10 Heating people, not rooms
- EN-11 Cold is a battery problem too
- EN-12 Why 45 °C is not hot, and why it is
- EN-13 The operating room as a test environment
- EN-14 Designing for the wash
- EN-15 What thermal cameras get wrong
1. Shiny surfaces
The camera assumes the surface emits infrared efficiently. Metals and metallized films do not. They emit little and mirror their surroundings. A warm heat-reflective lining can appear cold in an image, and a cool one can appear warm if it reflects a warm person. Images of such materials need a high-emissivity patch on the surface or contact sensors.
2. Reflections
A smooth surface reflects infrared the way a mirror reflects light. The warm shape in the image may be the operator, a lamp or a radiator behind the camera. Moving the camera a little shows it: a reflection moves, a real hot spot stays.
3. The color scale
Automatic scaling stretches the color range across whatever is in the frame. A difference of 1 °C can be shown as blue against red. Two images with different scales cannot be compared by eye. We fix the scale across a series and print it on every image.
4. Surfaces only
A camera reports the outer surface. It says nothing about the temperature under a cover, inside a pocket or at the skin. A cool outer surface on a jacket can mean little heat inside or excellent insulation. The image alone cannot tell which.
5. Angle and distance
Emissivity falls at steep viewing angles, so curved objects read cooler at their edges. At distance, each pixel covers a larger area and small hot spots are averaged away. Camera position is fixed and recorded for comparable images.
Marketing images
Product comparisons often show one garment glowing and another dark. Without the scale, the emissivity of each surface and the time since switching on, such images show nothing. A garment that glows on the outside is, if anything, losing heat to the room.
Using the camera well
- Use it for distribution and for differences in one frame.
- Use contact sensors for absolute values.
- Set and record emissivity.
- Fix the scale.
- Control the background.
- Record the time of each image against the power and sensor log.
Why we care
Thermal imaging is central to our work, which is the reason to be strict about it. An image we publish has to mean what it appears to mean.
See thermal imaging and the Knowledge article on infrared thermography.