THERMAL LAB · EN-02 · ENGINEERING NOTES
Warm air beats hot pads
Given the same number of watts, a large area of mild warmth makes a person feel warmer than a small area of strong heat. The reason lies in how skin senses temperature and how the body decides to distribute blood.
In this section
- EN-01 Why a heated jacket heats two rectangles
- EN-02 Warm air beats hot pads
- EN-03 The watt is the unit of warmth
- EN-04 What a data sheet does not tell you
- EN-05 Thin is a thermal property
- EN-06 Why we measure in watt-hours
- EN-07 The jacket you already own
- EN-08 The cost of an air leak
- EN-09 Feet and hands follow the core
- EN-10 Heating people, not rooms
- EN-11 Cold is a battery problem too
- EN-12 Why 45 °C is not hot, and why it is
- EN-13 The operating room as a test environment
- EN-14 Designing for the wash
- EN-15 What thermal cameras get wrong
How warmth is sensed
Skin does not measure heat flow. It carries temperature sensors that report local skin temperature and how fast it is changing. The brain forms its sense of thermal comfort largely from the average over a wide area, with extra weight on any region that is clearly cold.
A hot patch raises local skin temperature a great deal in one place and changes the average very little. A cold stomach or cold flanks still report cold, and the overall verdict stays cold.
Adaptation
Sensors under a hot pad adapt. After some minutes the patch feels less warm than it did, though nothing has changed. Wearers respond by raising the setting. The pad gets hotter, the battery drains faster and the rest of the body is no better off.
The body's response
Blood flow to the hands and feet follows the body's reading of its overall state. Broad warmth over the torso tells the body it has heat to spare. A hot patch does not send that message as strongly, because most of the torso's sensors disagree.
The ceiling
A surface against the body has a temperature it must not exceed. A small pad at that ceiling can deliver only so much. Warm air has a much lower temperature and a much larger contact area, the whole surface of the torso, and can deliver more total heat while every point stays mild. See surface temperature limits.
A room is the model
Nobody warms up by pressing a hot plate to their back. They walk into a warm room. The air is perhaps 22 °C (72 °F), far cooler than a heating pad, and it is comfortable because it is everywhere. A thermal layer under a jacket can make a small warm room around the torso.
What we measure
We do not rate a wearable heater by its surface temperature. We measure the temperature of the air around the torso at several points and how evenly it is held. That figure tracks what wearers tell us.
See the microclimate and temperature uniformity.