THERMAL LAB · ME-11 · METHODS
Method: repeatability and uncertainty
No measurement is exact. The useful question is how far a figure could be from the truth, and whether the difference between two results is larger than that. We report the spread with the number.
In this section
- ME-01 How we test
- ME-02 Method: thermal imaging
- ME-03 Method: contact temperature sensing
- ME-04 Method: power and energy measurement
- ME-05 Method: warm-up curves
- ME-06 Method: steady state and stability
- ME-07 Method: temperature uniformity
- ME-08 Method: side-by-side comparison
- ME-09 Method: cold conditions testing
- ME-10 Method: surface temperature limits
- ME-11 Method: repeatability and uncertainty
- ME-12 Standards we reference
- ME-13 Reading a thermal report
Two kinds of error
Random error makes repeated runs scatter. It shows up when the same test is repeated, and it shrinks when results are averaged.
Systematic error shifts every run the same way. A sensor that reads half a degree high does so every time. Repeating does not reveal it. Checking against a reference does.
Where spread comes from
| Source | Typical control |
|---|---|
| Sensor accuracy | Comparison check before each series |
| Sensor contact and position | Fixed, marked, photographed positions |
| Ambient drift | Logged, and runs rejected if it moves too far |
| Start temperature | Rest period before each run |
| Sample variation | More than one sample where available |
| Camera emissivity setting | Set and recorded for each surface |
| Assembly of the layer stack | Same order, same compression |
Repeat runs
For any result that drives a decision, the run is repeated at least three times, with the stack taken apart and rebuilt between runs. The range across repeats is the practical repeatability of that test.
Is the difference real?
If element A ends 1.5 °C warmer than element B, and repeats of the same element scatter by 2 °C, the test has not separated them. We say so. A difference is reported as real only when it clearly exceeds the repeatability.
Absolute and relative
Our methods are stronger at comparison than at absolute values. Comparing two samples in the same setup cancels most systematic errors, because both sides share them. Where an absolute figure is needed against a standard, an accredited laboratory using that standard's apparatus is the right source, and we say that too.
How figures are written
- Temperatures to one decimal, in °C with °F in brackets.
- Energy in watt-hours to one decimal.
- Times as hours, minutes and seconds.
- Every figure with its conditions and, where it matters, its repeatability.
A number without conditions is not a result. See reading a thermal report.